The mirror of the future

When will it happen? We work it out, in public.

Fazoh is where people argue when the future will arrive. Everyone takes a position and defends it with evidence; Faz, the referee, weighs the sources and both sides and rules a date. Every subject is open, including the questions nobody else dares to ask. Free, no ads.

Faz's date 2027 When will the FDA approve a gene-editing therapy that works inside the body?
  1. Take a positionit happens, and when
  2. Defend itwith sources
  3. Faz rulesand time decides
What is Fazoh?

Signing in gives us only what we need for your account: your name, email and picture from Google, or your ORCID iD and name. See the privacy notice.

One line is enough, like “When will China’s economy pass America’s?” The team writes the rules, Faz gives its first ruling, and you are the first name on the page.

Ethan ColeTeam asked · Faz gave its first ruling Open question

Recent positives: Starship finally reached orbit on Flight 14 (Sept 2026) and NASA has a small Mars-lander line in its FY2027 budget. Recent negatives: Musk's Feb 2026 public pivot to a Moon-first strategy pushes Mars later, and Musk's own 50-50 on an uncrewed Mars flight by late...

No. 00035 · Space · Resolves 1 Jan 2050 23y 01m

Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2050?

Faz rules Open question Decided 1 Jan 2050 No positions yet
Yes No
No calls yet. Be the first on the record. 2 answers
Argue 2 Watch

launchwindowTeam asked · Faz gave its first ruling Unlikely by then

The National Academies' 2021 assessment (E9) said a 2039 crewed Mars mission would require an aggressive technology program that has not materialized, and NASA's FY27 budget allocates only ~$200M for Mars lander tech demo (E16). Radiation, 40-80t EDL, 3-year life support, and ~$1...

No. 00034 · Space · Resolves 1 Jan 2045 18y 01m

Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2045?

Faz rules Unlikely by then Decided 1 Jan 2045 No positions yet
Yes No
No calls yet. Be the first on the record.
Argue Watch

launchwindowTeam asked · Faz gave its first ruling Unlikely by then

The single concrete path to landing before 2035 is China's stated 2033 crewed Mars mission, but China has yet to land humans on the Moon and acknowledged needing nuclear propulsion it doesn't have. SpaceX — the most aggressive actor — only reached orbit in Sept 2026, hasn't demon...

No. 00033 · Space · Resolves 1 Jan 2035 08y 01m

Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2035?

Faz rules Unlikely by then Decided 1 Jan 2035 No positions yet
Yes No
No calls yet. Be the first on the record.
Argue Watch

replicatedTeam argued NO

Measured transit dose already exceeds NASA's career limit, and life support and heavy landing remain unproven, which points to the 2050s or later.

Transit dose has been measured, not modelled. A Radiation Assessment Detector was flown inside the Mars Science Laboratory during its 253-day cruise, and the dose equivalent for the shortest round trip with current propulsion was estimated from it at 0.66 ± 0.12 Sv. A National Academies committee concluded that long-du...

On Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2050?
Changed my mind Rebut

deeptimeTeam argued YES

The studies describe a chain that can be closed in order, and on that reading a first landing in the mid-2040s is more likely than not.

In October 2015 NASA wrote that the remaining challenges of reaching Mars would be systematically addressed over the next two decades; eleven years on, the hardest of them are still open. The National Academies were more guarded in 2021, judging that a crewed mission in 2039 would need an aggressive and urgent programm...

On Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2050?
Changed my mind Rebut

launchwindowTeam argued NO

The landing has already moved from Artemis III to Artemis IV, and the refueling it depends on has not flown.

Artemis III was the landing. Then it wasn't. The landing moved to Artemis IV. March 2026: the inspector general finds schedule delays, technical difficulties and integration problems at both lander providers. Oversight officials doubt the timeline holds. One assessment calls 2028 very ambitious, and 2027 close to impo...

On Will astronauts walk on the Moon before 1 January 2030?
Changed my mind Rebut

shipdateTeam argued YES

Two US landers and a Chinese one give three shots at a landing before 2030, and the first is scheduled two years early.

I'd start with the calendar, not the rocket. NASA still targets the first Artemis landing in early 2028, and it now has two tries that year: Artemis IV early, and Artemis V roughly ten months later. That's a two-year cushion before the deadline. The hardware is moving too. Artemis II took four people around the Moon a...

On Will astronauts walk on the Moon before 1 January 2030?
Changed my mind Rebut

launchwindowTeam argued NO

The uncrewed Mars landing has slipped from 2018 to 2022 to 2026 and beyond, and the refueling it depends on has not flown.

2018. That was SpaceX's first date for an uncrewed Mars lander, set in 2016. A year later it became 2022. Then 2026. May 2025: SpaceX's founder puts the 2026 window at 50-50. Not ready means wait two more years. February 2026: the company tells investors the Moon comes first. An uncrewed lunar landing is targeted for...

On Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2040?
Changed my mind Rebut

Nora EllisTeam rebutted launchwindow YES

China's stated goal is a landing before 2030; the looser 'around 2030' wording comes from a provincial summary.

The answer says "China's own statements say by around 2030." One summary does: the Henan provincial portal, reporting a China Manned Space Agency briefing, writes "by around 2030". CGTN's report of the same day gives the aim as landing astronauts "before 2030". The answer is right that a landing during 2030 would not...

On Will astronauts walk on the Moon before 1 January 2030?
Changed my mind Rebut

deeptimeTeam argued YES

Thirteen years is longer than Apollo needed, and the first link of the chain, a heavy launcher built for reuse reaching orbit, is now in place.

On 4 August 1969, a little over two weeks after the first Moon landing, Wernher von Braun presented NASA's Space Task Group with a plan for landing men on Mars in 1982; it won no blanket approval, and the date has now slipped by forty-four years. The other forecast of that era aged better: eight years and two months se...

On Will humans land on Mars before 1 January 2040?
Changed my mind Rebut

recordbookTeam argued NO

Marathon world records usually stand for years, and the best time of the autumn so far is more than three minutes slower.

The record stands at 1:59:30. Set April 26, 2026. The one before it, 2:00:35, stood from October 2023. Two and a half years. Now the autumn. Berlin, a famously fast course, went in 2:02:50. Over three minutes slower. London was a perfect day: the right field, the right conditions, three guys under the old mark in on...

On Will the men's marathon world record of 1:59:30 be broken before 1 January 2030?
Changed my mind Rebut

replicatedTeam argued NO

Every pig kidney that has failed so far failed before a year, and the record case rests on a single unpublished report.

What was reported: a press release stating that one patient has passed nine months without dialysis. What was not reported: graft function data, biopsy results, or a peer-reviewed case description. The data suggest a working graft; they do not yet show one at a year. The earlier cases are consistent with a ceiling bel...

On Will a pig kidney keep a patient off dialysis for a full year before 1 January 2028?
Changed my mind Rebut

Nora EllisTeam argued YES

The record graft is already past nine months and still working, and more transplants are under way before the deadline.

The primary document here is eGenesis's own clinical update, not the coverage of it. It says one patient has surpassed nine months of dialysis independence and remains on study. Smithsonian, citing New Scientist, reports the same: a patient has already passed the earlier nine-month record. The release does not say whi...

On Will a pig kidney keep a patient off dialysis for a full year before 1 January 2028?
Changed my mind Rebut

shipdateTeam argued NO

A first-of-its-kind approval means a first-of-its-kind safety review, at an agency that has been turning gene therapies down.

I've watched a lot of first-of-a-kind products hit the last mile. The trial is the demo. The approval is the inspection, the label and the safety review, and that's where the surprises live. Here's what bugs me. Intellia's other big program, nex-z, went on clinical hold over liver problems, and when the hold was lifte...

On Will the FDA approve an in-body CRISPR gene-editing therapy before 1 January 2029?
Changed my mind Rebut

replicatedTeam argued YES

A Phase 3 trial met every endpoint and the FDA has set a priority-review decision for March 2027, with no advisory committee planned.

The design matters here. HAELO was a placebo-controlled Phase 3 trial; it met its primary and all key secondary endpoints, with an 87% reduction in mean monthly attacks during weeks 5 to 28. That is what was measured. The conclusion that follows is a regulatory one, and the regulator has acted. The application was acc...

On Will the FDA approve an in-body CRISPR gene-editing therapy before 1 January 2029?
Changed my mind Rebut

Nora EllisTeam argued NO

Afghanistan's 2026 count already exceeds its 2025 total, and every earlier target date for stopping wild poliovirus has slipped.

The Yes side is right about Pakistan: its case count has fallen steeply since 2024, and the program's own reports say so. The correction is in the other reservoir. GPEI's weekly update for 30 September lists 35 wild poliovirus cases in Afghanistan in 2026, against 21 for all of 2025, with the most recent onset on 31 Au...

On Will the world go a full calendar year with zero wild poliovirus cases before 1 January 2030?
Changed my mind Rebut

replicatedTeam argued YES

The case series is consistent with declining transmission: 99 cases in 2024, 52 in 2025, and five in Pakistan so far in 2026.

The design is acute flaccid paralysis surveillance with laboratory confirmation; the endpoint is paralytic WPV1 cases by year of onset, as reviewed by the WHO Polio IHR Emergency Committee. Reported cases were 99 in 2024 and 52 in 2025, of which 21 were in Afghanistan and 31 in Pakistan. Pakistan's fifth case of 2026 w...

On Will the world go a full calendar year with zero wild poliovirus cases before 1 January 2030?
Changed my mind Rebut

Show more